Skip to content
reefcalcs

White spots on fish (ich): freshwater and marine treatment

Symptom: Small white dots like grains of salt on the body and fins; fish flashing, scratching or breathing fast.

Likely causes, ranked

1. Freshwater ich (Ichthyophthirius multifiliis)

very common

DiagnosticFreshwater tank; white dots, blisters or salt-grain spots on skin and fins; earlier, flashing, extra mucus and poor appetite. Gill-only infections may show no spots but kill fish quickly (UF/IFAS).

FixUF/IFAS: only the free-swimming theront is vulnerable, and at 75–79 °F the whole cycle takes about 3–6 days. Salt at 4–5 g/L as a prolonged bath for 7–10 days kills theronts (they can't tolerate 3–5 ppt, and most freshwater fish tolerate 5 ppt for weeks), but plants may not tolerate it; formalin at 25 mg/L (1 mL per 10 gallons), half that for sensitive species, is the other standard treatment. At warm temperatures treat daily for at least 3–5 treatments, and keep going until deaths stop. Don't use copper sulfate when alkalinity is below 50 mg/L. Formalin and copper are hazardous to people as well as fish: follow the product label's safety directions.

2. Marine ich (Cryptocaryon irritans)

very common

DiagnosticSaltwater tank; salt-grain white spots on body and fins, flashing; tangs are especially prone (UF/IFAS).

FixTreat in a hospital tank, never the reef display: copper held at 0.15–0.20 mg/L free copper for 3–6 weeks and tested at least twice a day, or the tank-transfer method, moving fish to a clean, dry tank every three days (UF/IFAS, Bulk Reef Supply). Copper kills most invertebrates, and calcium carbonate rock and sand bind it.

3. Marine velvet (Amyloodinium)

less common

DiagnosticSaltwater fish sick or dying, sometimes before any spots are obvious; velvet can kill before spots appear (UF/IFAS).

FixCopper for at least 10–14 days (UF/IFAS); a freshwater dip alone isn't an effective treatment, and Bulk Reef Supply doesn't recommend tank transfer for velvet. Act fast.

Common myths

ClaimOnce the spots are gone, it's cured.

RealityUF/IFAS: the parasite multiplies off the fish, and survivors can carry it. Keep treating until deaths have stopped.

ClaimCaptive-bred fish don't need quarantine.

RealityCORAL Magazine recommends quarantining every incoming marine fish, captive-bred included, and UF/IFAS recommends a minimum 30-day quarantine for freshwater fish.

Questions

How do you treat ich in a freshwater tank?

UF/IFAS gives salt at 4–5 g/L for 7–10 days at 75–79 °F, or formalin at 25 mg/L (half for sensitive species), with daily treatments at warm temperatures until deaths stop. Check plants' and fish's tolerance first.

How long does ich treatment take?

At least several life cycles: about 3–6 days each at 75–79 °F, longer in cool water (UF/IFAS). Marine copper treatment runs 3–6 weeks.

Can I treat marine ich in a reef tank?

Not with copper: it kills most invertebrates and is bound by rock and sand. Move fish to a hospital tank.

What causes ich?

A parasite that arrives on new fish or plants; outbreaks favour quick temperature changes (UF/IFAS). Quarantine new arrivals.

Is freshwater ich the same as marine ich?

No: freshwater ich is Ichthyophthirius multifiliis and marine ich is Cryptocaryon irritans, different parasites with different treatments.

Sources & references

  1. 1.
  2. 2.
  3. 3.
    Yanong — Use of copper in marine aquaculture and aquarium systems, UF/IFAS FA165
    https://extension.rwfm.tamu.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/8/2013/09/Use-of-Copper-in-Marine-Aquaculture-and-Aquarium-Systems.pdf
  4. 4.
    Reed & Francis-Floyd — Amyloodinium infections of marine fish, UF/IFAS VM-90
    https://extension.rwfm.tamu.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/8/2013/09/Amyloodinium-Infections-of-Marine-Fish.pdf
  5. 5.
    Bulk Reef Supply — Knock out saltwater fish ich using the tank transfer method
    https://www.bulkreefsupply.com/content/post/know-out-ich-using-the-tank-transfer-method-fish-health-ep11
  6. 6.

Last reviewed